Wikipedia talk:Featured and good topic questions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Scarlett Johansson[edit]

3 articles
Featured article Scarlett Johansson
Scarlett Johansson by Gage Skidmore 2 (cropped, 2).jpg
Featured list Awards and nominations
Featured list On screen and stage

Filled this out as a candidate and was about to click publish when I noticed the existence of Scarlett Johansson discography. Not sure how far away it is from FL status, but if someone wants to take it on, then the set would be complete. AllegedlyHuman (talk) 11:40, 27 April 2021 (UTC)[]

Similarly, Bruno Mars seems to just be missing List of songs written by Bruno Mars: the main is at GA and there's four FLs (discography, videography, awards and nominations, songs recorded). AllegedlyHuman (talk) 10:05, 29 April 2021 (UTC)[]
Yeah, these look like good scopes if those lists can be featured. — Bilorv (talk) 16:33, 29 April 2021 (UTC)[]
On a related note a similar situation can be said of Anne Hathaway which a I believe would just need the list of awards to be FL to become a topic.  Spy-cicle💥  Talk? 08:18, 3 May 2021 (UTC)[]
Actually looking around at the high-profile actor articles there are many that are very close 1 article/list away from being able to become featured topics (have listed some below if anyone is interested but do not quote me as it is possible I may have missed out a related article that may be within the scope of the topic). Regards  Spy-cicle💥  Talk? 09:19, 3 May 2021 (UTC)[]
Extended content
3 articles
Featured article Anne Hathaway
Anne Hathaway for AHC.png
List-Class article Awards and nominations
Featured list Performances
4 articles
Featured article Kate Winslet
Kate Winslet at the 2017 Toronto International Film Festival (cropped).jpg
List-Class article Awards and nominations
Featured list Performances
Demoted article Golden Hat Foundation (probably needed)
3 articles
Good article Meryl Streep
Meryl Streep by Jack Mitchell.jpg
List-Class article Awards and nominations
Featured list On screen and stage
3 articles
Good article Keanu Reeves
Reunião com o ator norte-americano Keanu Reeves (46806576944) (cropped).jpg
List-Class article Awards and nominations
Featured list Filmography
3 articles
Demoted article Natalie Portman
Natalie Portman (48470988352) (cropped).jpg
Featured list Awards and nominations
Featured list Filmography
4 articles
Featured article Brad Pitt
Brad Pitt Inglorious Basterds Berlin premiere.jpg
Featured list Awards and nominations
Featured list Filmography
Demoted article Plan B Entertainment
Late response, but surely the Scarlett Johansson topic would need to include Anywhere I Lay My Head, Break Up (album), and "Relator" (song) under discography as well? – Rhain 04:43, 22 July 2021 (UTC)[]
@Rhain: (not sure how active you are in this TP so pinged), That is a fair point. However if the discography is included (plus the others) and the topic is called say "Overview of Scarlett Johansson" those songs and albums I think can reasonable be included under that list. Then a subsequent subtopic about her discography with all albums (and possibly songs) could be included under that instead. Regards  Spy-cicle💥  Talk? 21:00, 29 July 2021 (UTC)[]
Example of how it could look like
4 articles
Featured article Scarlett Johansson
Scarlett Johansson by Gage Skidmore 2 (cropped, 2).jpg
Featured list Awards and nominations
Featured list On screen and stage
List-Class article Discography(subtopic)
I believe that would work, though I think the discography subtopic would need to be nominated first (or simultaneously). Not entirely sure. Not very active here—I just stumbled across this and thought I'd make a comment—so I appreciate the ping. – Rhain 13:24, 30 July 2021 (UTC)[]
@Rhain: Per the precedents at Wikipedia:Featured_topics#Music (one example overview) we usually do not require such subtopics for the overview topic to occur. Regards  Spy-cicle💥  Talk? 18:48, 30 July 2021 (UTC)[]

Inuit clothing[edit]

Hello, in the process of getting Inuit clothing to GA (and now at FAC), I spawned two child articles off it, history of Inuit clothing (current GAN) and research on Inuit clothing (GA passed). Assuming that History passes GA, would those three articles alone be sufficient for a Good Topic? There are articles about individual Inuit garments (amauti and mukluk for example), so I don't know if they would have to be included, or if just the broad overview articles would count. ♠PMC(talk) 22:49, 22 May 2021 (UTC)[]

  • I've got no relevant subject knowledge here, but in general just overview articles should be fine if they're exhaustive, without need to have every notable individual type of clothing included. — Bilorv (talk) 11:27, 23 May 2021 (UTC)[]
  • Thanks, much appreciated. ♠PMC(talk) 14:04, 24 May 2021 (UTC)[]
  • No problem, feel free to ping me if there's a GT nom in future. — Bilorv (talk) 17:56, 24 May 2021 (UTC)[]

Spider-man films topic now meets criteria?[edit]

Looking over at Wikipedia:Former featured and good topics, I noticed Wikipedia:Featured topics/Spider-Man films seems to meet the crieria again since every main line Spider-man film is a GA, with the recent repromotion of Spider-Man 2 early this year. Not a significant contributor so I thought I should ask here first. Regards  Spy-cicle💥  Talk? 16:16, 19 June 2021 (UTC)[]

No subject knowledge on this, but from reading Spider-Man in film it looks like Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse should be included, and it's also a GA so that's fine. There'd be a few months of grace period, but Spider-Man: No Way Home will need to get to GA soon after its release (currently scheduled for December 2021). — Bilorv (talk) 16:49, 23 June 2021 (UTC)[]

Category:Featured topics articles by quality[edit]

Hello, Featured & Good topic folks,

I was wondering whether, since this group works with Featured & Good articles, you all needed the empty categories that don't deal with Featured & Good articles. Do you expect any scenario where, say, a Featured topic would be a B-Class or Stub article? If not, perhaps they can be deleted. I've been going through a lot of unused WikiProject empty categories, most of which were created in 2006-2008 and not used over the past decade+ period. Liz Read! Talk! 20:57, 29 July 2021 (UTC)[]

I am not a delegate or director so they will be able to answer this better for you but there sometimes occassions when topics are promoted that are not FA/FL/GA after being peer-reviewed (For example a list may be ineligle for FL so instead it is peer reviewed before being added to said topic). This is mentioned at WP:FTCRITERIA 3.c. Regards  Spy-cicle💥  Talk? 18:06, 7 August 2021 (UTC)[]